Currently free to try
Skip to content
NINEHOUNDTHE EASTERN OBSERVATORY

Famous lives / NINEHOUND JOURNAL

Elon Musk: after three failures, would the fourth rocket fly?

A rocket does not travel farther because its founder sounds certain. In 2008, SpaceX first had to reach an orbit before it could deliver a larger promise.

NineHound · 2026-11-124 min read中文原文
01

Before the fourth attempt, there were three failures

Remove Elon Musk’s name from the later headlines and return to 2008. The question becomes more limited and more severe: Falcon 1 has failed to reach orbit on three attempts. Should there be a fourth?

A reader who knows the ending can treat those failures as preparation. For the people being asked to keep working, investing or trusting the company, preparation was not yet an established description. They had unsuccessful flights to explain. They did not have a document guaranteeing that the next attempt would work.

NASA’s history of Commercial Orbital Transportation Services records Falcon 1’s first successful orbital flight on 28 September 2008, following three unsuccessful attempts. The date fits neatly on a timeline. The uncertainty before it does not. A rocket has no obligation to cooperate with the shape of a founder’s future biography.

02

What persistence owes to other people

A failed launch affects more than hardware. Employees decide how much of their working lives to commit. Partners plan around the next attempt. Customers consider whether their missions can wait. A founder can announce that the company will continue, but cannot make all those costs disappear by expressing determination.

Serious persistence therefore owes an explanation of what will differ next time. Repeating a wish more loudly produces greater volume. Identifying a failure, making a change and arranging a test may produce useful evidence. That is a standard for judging a continuing experiment, rather than a reconstruction of every internal SpaceX decision.

The familiar image of one extraordinary individual also leaves something out. Engineering requires many people to make their respective contributions work together. Removing the team simplifies the story while weakening its explanation. The fourth flight’s success was ultimately a technical result achieved collectively.

03

A contract was another beginning

In December 2008, NASA awarded SpaceX an original commercial resupply contract worth $1.6 billion for twelve station cargo missions. Placed immediately after the orbital success, it makes an attractive ending: the rocket worked and the large customer arrived.

The chronology needs another entry. NASA had selected SpaceX as a Commercial Orbital Transportation Services partner in 2006 to develop Falcon 9 and Dragon. Falcon 1’s successful flight and the later procurement were different milestones. The small rocket was not the entire transport system required by the cargo agreement, and the agreement was not a prize handed over for a single successful launch.

A contract represents confidence in a future service and an obligation to provide it. Its headline value is not money instantly received as profit. Further development and demonstrations were still necessary. NASA’s retrospective records completion of SpaceX’s COTS demonstration programme in 2012.

This makes the achievement more substantial. A founder’s ambition had to become a working vehicle, a credible relationship with partners and a service a customer needed. Each connection mattered. None could be supplied simply by declaring the destination more boldly.

04

Reading danger through the image of Kan

In the I Ching, Kan is associated with water and danger. Beside this episode, it offers a way to discuss movement through difficulty: recognise the obstruction and find the conditions for passage. Conviction does not oblige an obstruction to move. We are using a cultural comparison here, not casting a hexagram for Musk.

The fourth attempt matters because trying again eventually met an unforgiving test. Reaching orbit and failing to reach orbit are different outcomes regardless of the speaker’s confidence. Language can alter the audience’s feelings; it cannot alter that distinction.

Danger can also make every retreat look cowardly and every further commitment look brave. A successful ending encourages that mistake. One success cannot justify every similar gamble. The ability to absorb failure, the presence of new evidence and the costs borne by other people remain relevant to the decision.

05

The difficult part to copy

Copying a founder’s manner is easier than copying a team’s treatment of failure. The first can happen immediately. The second requires attention to records that are repetitive and sometimes unwelcome: where the result fell short, which assumption failed and which condition is still missing.

If the lesson is only that persistence wins, the three unsuccessful flights have taught too little. They should make the reasons for continuing more specific and its costs more visible. Being able to explain what will change next time is the beginning of understanding the fourth attempt.

Sources and further reading

This essay examines historical milestones from 2006 to 2012. Kan is used as a cultural comparison, not a divination cast or a claim about Musk’s birth chart.

Try it for yourself.

Clarify a present question ↗

Keep exploring

All articles ↗