From the classics / NINEHOUND JOURNAL
Confucius and the I Ching: Repeated Reading and Changing Questions
The most interesting part is that a man later called a sage still felt he had not fully understood the book.
The leather bindings do not mean three books
The Hereditary House of Confucius in the Records of the Grand Historian says that he enjoyed the Changes in later life and describes repeated reading through leather bindings breaking three times. The usual explanation is that the leather cords joining the slips wore through repeatedly. The image emphasizes persistent reading, not only three readings or three ruined paper-bound books.
The passage then says he wished for more years to understand the Changes further. Before turning it into a motivational maxim, consider its unfinished quality. If even this biographical figure still has more to learn, classifying everything in the world after learning a few hexagram names seems hasty.
The same words change with their position
Beginners easily collect labels: Qian is enterprising, Kun receptive, one hexagram good and another bad. Labels help memory, but may fail when circumstances change. Who can act, who must wait, whether conditions are sufficient, and how far things have progressed all change what a sentence means in practice.
Consider an illustrative scenario. A newly started project with resources still missing and a mature project whose partner awaits a decision require very different actions under the same advice to act promptly. The former may need missing conditions supplied first; the latter may need a commitment implemented now. This is a modern teaching example, not a business case from the ancient book.
Read a hexagram before rushing to fortune labels
Read the judgment first, then follow the line positions to see how the situation moves. Consult annotations for unfamiliar words. Where interpretations differ, ask whether the disagreement concerns vocabulary, image selection, or divination method. Writing your own question beside the text can be more useful than searching for sentences that agree with you.
Finally, explain it in your own words: whom does this passage address, what conditions do they have, and what can they do now? If that cannot be said, the difficulty usually lies in unresolved relationships rather than a missing mystical term.
Repeated reading can also correct the reader
The broken bindings leave an image of reading, not a final state of omniscience. A younger reader might see only advance in a passage and later recognize endurance, withdrawal, and waiting. Interpretation changes, but so do the questions brought to the book.
The formation and authorship of the Commentaries to the Changes remain separate scholarly questions. This biographical passage cannot prove Confucius personally wrote every chapter. A story can be moving while textual sources retain their distinct status. Reading again in that spirit avoids turning a fine story into a universal stamp of authority.
Sources and further reading
- Records of the Grand Historian, volume 47: Hereditary House of Confucius ↗
- Chinese Text Project: parallel passage on Confucius reading the Changes ↗
This article discusses the Changes-reading narrative in the Records of the Grand Historian. Modern examples and reading suggestions are NineHound commentary, not words attributed to Confucius.
Try it for yourself.
Begin with a specific question ↗NineHound Changes reading ↗Questions before you start
What does the story of Confucius breaking the bindings mean?
The biography in the Records of the Grand Historian describes repeated study through the image of leather bindings wearing out. The usual explanation concerns the cords joining written slips, not three paper books or only three readings. The article uses that image to discuss sustained study and the willingness to recognize that an important text still has more to teach.
Did Confucius write every I Ching commentary?
The article does not treat the broken-bindings story as proof that Confucius wrote every commentary. A biographical account of reading and the formation or authorship of the commentarial texts are separate questions. Keeping those evidence types distinct lets the story remain meaningful without using it as a universal authority claim for every part of the received book.
How can I study an I Ching hexagram more carefully?
Read the judgment, follow the line positions and consult annotations for unfamiliar words. When interpretations differ, identify whether the disagreement concerns vocabulary, imagery or method. Then explain the passage in your own words: whom does it address, what conditions are present and what action is possible? That exercise tests understanding more effectively than collecting agreeable quotations.
Why can the same I Ching passage suggest different actions?
The situation affects how advice applies. A project lacking essential resources and a mature project awaiting a decision may need different responses to a call for action. The article uses hypothetical modern scenarios to demonstrate that distinction. Repeated reading can reveal those conditions more clearly as the reader’s questions change, without making every interpretation equally well supported.